France’s student protests highlight a debt crisis that could spill over to the rest of Europe法国学生抗议活动凸显了可能蔓延至欧洲其他地区的债务危机。
France’s unprecedented wave of student protests has laid bare the country’s growing financial pressures, which will only become more difficult to tackle as Europe’s second-largest economy tries to rein in a ballooning budget deficit.

Stefano Guidi/Getty Images
France’s unprecedented wave of student protests has laid bare the country’s growing financial pressures, which will only become more difficult to tackle as Europe’s second-largest economy tries to rein in a ballooning budget deficit.
The country’s finances are in a precarious state. Public debt was more than $4 trillion in June, exceeding the size of the economy, according to the country’s statistics agency . The cost of servicing that debt has climbed by billions of dollars on last year, as bond yields spike .
At the same time, demands on the public purse are rising: Pension costs have climbed because of an aging population while the government looks to spend more on defense.
High school students, meanwhile, have called for a fix to staff shortages, overcrowded classrooms and crumbling school infrastructure.
Solutions to France’s financial troubles have led to social unrest in the past. Efforts to raise the retirement age sparked widespread protests in 2023 .
French school protests grow as workers join students
Last week, the French government proposed deep spending cuts and tax hikes aimed at narrowing the budget deficit, but bond buyers are concerned that fiscal measures may be watered down by lawmakers ahead of presidential elections next year, said Andrew Kenningham, chief European economist at consultancy Capital Economics.
The election could see President Emmanuel Macron ousted by either a far-right or far-left successor, raising questions over the country’s commitment to fiscal discipline. While Marine Le Pen’s right-wing National Rally recently proposed substantial spending cuts meant to stabilize the public finances, her party also remains committed to costly tax reductions, Kenningham said.
“Investors will also be concerned about greater fiscal populism after the elections,” he wrote in a note last week. “There is a big risk that spreads rise a lot further, either before or after next year’s elections.”
Worries about a potential debt crisis in France boiled over last week, leading to a selloff in French bonds and a sharp rise in yields.
The spread between French and German bond yields expanded to its widest level since 2012. That difference in yields means investors are demanding much higher returns to hold debt from France compared with Germany, which is deemed a safer alternative.
The French bond rout has sparked fears of spillovers to other high-yield European debt markets, with some analysts drawing parallels with the eurozone debt crisis of the early 2010s .
Saul Loeb/AFP/Getty Images
Global bond sell-off deepens, sending borrowing costs higher around the world
Given France’s size and systemic importance, “the potential for contagion into other countries and the Eurozone at large is very large and could potentially cause a serious crisis for the entire region,” Angel Talavera, chief European economist at Oxford Economics, an advisory firm, told CNN.
These worries in large part pushed the euro to its weakest level against the dollar since May 2025 on Monday. The currency, shared by 21 countries in the European Union, is worth around $1.12, having briefly dipped below that level.
The latest ructions in markets could weigh on a fragile economic recovery in Europe, bolstered by investment into artificial intelligence, stronger demand for European exports and higher defense spending in Germany.
Recent survey data showed that activity in manufacturing and services in the euro area increased at its fastest pace in nearly three-and-a-half years last month.
“(Economic) growth is staging a comeback and Europe has shown surprising resilience,” economists at Morgan Stanley wrote in a late September note.
Stephanie Lecocq/Reuters
Fall of yet another premier will make it hard for France to fix its finances. What’s behind its debt problem?
High bond yields are a clear risk to that growth, however.
If governments don’t cut spending , “interest rates will continue to go up,” Carsten Brzeski, head of macroeconomics at Dutch bank ING told CNN.
Higher bond yields push up the cost of borrowing throughout the economy, making home and car purchases more expensive and driving down investment. They also make it more expensive for governments to borrow money and force a certain degree of austerity to stop yields from rising further.
Yields on French, German and UK government bonds have broken multi-year records in recent weeks as concerns mount about the sustainability of public debt loads.
Europe’s public finances pose “serious risks to eurozone financial markets and to the economy,” Jack Allen-Reynolds, deputy chief eurozone economist at Capital Economics, told CNN.
Stefano Guidi/Getty Images
法国史无前例的学生抗议浪潮暴露了该国日益增长的财政压力,随着欧洲第二大经济体法国努力控制不断膨胀的预算赤字,这些压力只会变得更加难以应对。
该国财政状况岌岌可危。据该国统计机构的数据,截至6月份,公共债务超过4万亿美元,超过了经济总量。由于债券收益率飙升,偿债成本较去年增加了数十亿美元。
与此同时,公共财政的需求也在不断增长:由于人口老龄化,养老金成本不断攀升,而政府也希望在国防上投入更多资金。
与此同时,高中生们呼吁解决师资短缺、教室拥挤和学校基础设施破败等问题。
法国过去解决财政困境的方案都曾引发社会动荡。例如,2023年提高退休年龄的举措就引发了大规模抗议。
法国学校抗议活动愈演愈烈,工人加入学生行列。
上周,法国政府提议大幅削减开支并提高税收,以缩小预算赤字。但咨询公司凯投宏观(Capital Economics)首席欧洲经济学家安德鲁·肯宁汉姆(Andrew Kenningham)表示,债券买家担心,在明年总统大选之前,这些财政措施可能会被立法者淡化。
此次选举可能导致总统埃马纽埃尔·马克龙被极右翼或极左翼的继任者取代,引发人们对法国财政纪律承诺的质疑。肯宁汉姆表示,尽管玛丽娜·勒庞领导的右翼国民联盟近期提出了旨在稳定公共财政的大幅削减开支方案,但该党仍然坚持代价高昂的减税措施。
“投资者还会担心选举后财政民粹主义抬头,”他上周在一份报告中写道。“利差有很大的风险会进一步扩大,无论是在明年选举之前还是之后。”
上周,人们对法国潜在债务危机的担忧彻底爆发,导致法国债券遭到抛售,收益率大幅上升。
法国和德国债券收益率之间的利差扩大至2012年以来的最高水平。这种收益率差异意味着,与被视为更安全的德国债券相比,投资者要求持有法国债券的回报要高得多。
法国债券暴跌引发了人们对其他高收益欧洲债券市场可能出现溢出效应的担忧,一些分析师将其与 2010 年代初的欧元区债务危机相提并论。
Saul Loeb/AFP/Getty Images
全球债券抛售加剧,推高全球借贷成本
鉴于法国的体量和系统重要性,“疫情蔓延到其他国家和整个欧元区的可能性非常大,并有可能给整个地区带来严重的危机,”牛津经济咨询公司首席欧洲经济学家安赫尔·塔拉韦拉告诉 CNN。
这些担忧在很大程度上导致欧元周一兑美元汇率跌至2025年5月以来的最低水平。欧元是欧盟21个成员国的通用货币,目前价值约为1.12美元,此前曾短暂跌破该水平。
最新的市场动荡可能会对欧洲脆弱的经济复苏造成压力,而欧洲经济复苏的动力来自于对人工智能的投资、对欧洲出口的强劲需求以及德国不断增长的国防开支。
最新调查数据显示,上个月欧元区制造业和服务业活动增速创近三年半以来新高。
摩根士丹利的经济学家在9月下旬的一份报告中写道:“(经济)增长正在复苏,欧洲展现出了令人惊讶的韧性。”
Stephanie Lecocq/路透社
又一位总理下台,将使法国更难解决其财政问题。法国债务问题的根源究竟是什么?
然而,高债券收益率显然会对这种增长构成风险。
荷兰国际集团宏观经济主管卡斯滕·布热斯基告诉美国有线电视新闻网,如果各国政府不削减开支,“利率将继续上升”。
债券收益率上升会推高整个经济体的借贷成本,导致购房和购车成本上涨,并抑制投资。同时,债券收益率上升也会增加政府的借贷成本,迫使政府采取一定程度的财政紧缩措施,以阻止收益率进一步攀升。
近几周来,由于人们对公共债务负担的可持续性日益担忧,法国、德国和英国政府债券的收益率均打破了多年来的纪录。
凯投宏观(Capital Economics)欧元区副首席经济学家杰克·艾伦-雷诺兹(Jack Allen-Reynolds)告诉CNN,欧洲的公共财政对欧元区金融市场和经济构成“严重风险”。