How Israeli firm’s ‘zero-click’ malware attack poses global security risk以色列公司“零点击”恶意软件攻击如何构成全球安全风险
A new ‘zero-click’ hack uses ads to target victims without any action needed on their part.
![Al Jazeera Media Network on Thursday said it condemns the spyware attacks targeting a number of its staff [Showkat Shafi/Al Jazeera]](https://www.aljazeera.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/IMG_5926-1-1792084347.jpg?resize=770%2C513&quality=80)
A new ‘zero-click’ hack uses ads to target victims without any action needed on their part.
Al Jazeera Media Network on Thursday said it condemns the spyware attacks targeting a number of its staff [Showkat Shafi/Al Jazeera]
Just visiting a page or refreshing an app can be enough to fall victim to a malware attack in which your personal data is stolen from a laptop or phone, researchers have found. You are not even required to “click” on anything.
An Israeli spyware firm has been found to be behind the first-known instance of “zero-click” targeted advertising in which fraudsters or spies can steal private data and send it to external servers, with Al Jazeera journalists among the victims.
list 1 of 3 A world on trial: How lawyers documenting Israeli abuse pay a price
list 2 of 3 EU lawmaker investigating surveillance hacked by Israeli spyware, report says
list 3 of 3 UK, US, Netherlands warn of Iran-linked spyware
In June 2025, 45 devices used by Al Jazeera staff – including several who reported on sensitive subjects – were targeted with spyware which installed itself without the need to open or download any files.
An investigation by the Canada-based academic research unit Citizen Lab, prompted by Al Jazeera’s initial internal probe into the issue, discovered that the Israeli company Candiru was behind the attacks.
Analysts say the findings are “incredibly concerning”, as they confirm the existence of a new global security threat. “We knew we were headed in this direction and now it is out in the public,” Remesh Srinivasan, professor of information studies at the University of California in Los Angeles, US, told Al Jazeera.
“This is the next level, because people are being microtargeted,” he said. “This is the point we’ve come to when it comes to surveillance.”
How ‘zero-click’ malware works
Al Jazeera’s in-house technology team first discovered unusual patterns on devices used by some journalists in 2024. Analysis of network logs provided to the Citizen Lab by Al Jazeera in 2025 provided a clear temporal signature of how the attack was executed.
Malicious advertisements were bought by Discover-Tech, an Israeli company presenting itself as a legitimate advertising firm, but which actually operates as a facilitator for mercenary spyware partners.
Its advertisement network identified Al Jazeera staff, then quietly redirected them to an infected server belonging to Candiru. The spyware firm was blacklisted by the US government in 2021, when Citizen Lab found it was responsible for the illegal hacking and surveillance of at least 100 activists , journalists and political activists across 10 countries.
Al Jazeera Media Network has condemned the targeting of its staff members’ devices and called for those responsible to be held accountable.
Cybersecurity analyst and author Eddy Willems said the advertisements used automatically infect devices the moment they pop up on the screen, but there is an important technical nuance. “Executing code inside the browser does not automatically give an attacker full control over the computer,” Willems told Al Jazeera.
“To escape the browser’s isolated environment – the ‘sandbox’ – the attacker may need a second vulnerability,” Willems said, adding that an advanced spyware operation can combine several vulnerabilities.
“The attacker attempts to exploit vulnerabilities to bypass security boundaries. This is precisely what makes this type of attack so dangerous,” the analyst said.
Once the device is infected, the malicious software is designed to collect a wide range of sensitive data, including files, documents, and browser data such as cookies, bookmarks, and saved credentials.
It can also capture keystrokes, take screenshots, record microphone and webcam input, and extract emails and messages from popular communication platforms. To avoid triggering security mechanisms, the spyware often uses encrypted communication channels and breaks up stolen data into smaller chunks sent over time.
Advertising: A new global security threat?
Analysts say Citizen Lab’s findings point to the escalation of an existing threat, which expands the scale and reach of traditional cyberattacks and makes them much harder to detect.
While “zero-click” attacks are not completely new, the findings outline a new technique through which online advertisements are used as a route to infection.
Stephen O’Shaughnessy, a lecturer in cybersecurity at the TU Dublin Blanchardstown campus in Ireland, explained that when a user opens a website or app, an automated auction sells the advertisement space in a fraction of a second. That auction shares data about the victim, including the device ID, IP address, rough location and the app or site they are on.
“Discover-Tech posed as an ordinary advertiser, used that data to find their target and win the auction for that person’s screen,” O’Shaughnessy told Al Jazeera. “Anyone with a phone or browser that shows ads can be reached, without the attacker needing their phone number or email.”
“Because no message or link is involved, there is almost nothing for the victim to notice,” he added.
Discover-Tech appeared on lists of “certified” and “approved” vendors maintained by Google and advertising industry association IAB Europe, and has served advertisements via major networks such as Google, Yandex and Beeswax.
In its report, Citizen Lab said this illustrates the structural flaws in the online advertising system, which essentially failed to detect or prevent the abuse.
Discover-Tech advertisements have popped up on devices used by personnel in national-security-sensitive networks around the world, including those of various ministries of defence, armed forces, national cyber agencies, intergovernmental organisations and media outlets, Citizen Lab found.
The research unit said these advertisements have also appeared on networks used by the United Nations, NATO, the European Parliament, the European Commission and the Council of the European Union’s General Secretariat.
‘Almost nobody was watching’
Government networks have also been targeted in at least 24 countries, including the United States, Italy, Denmark, Norway, Australia, Russia, Mexico and Israel itself. Networks of media organisations have also been targeted, mainly in Australia, Denmark and Sweden, according to Citizen Lab.
In a separate report, New York-based advertising security firm Confiant said its own investigations had found that some of Discover-Tech’s advertisements also appeared in critical networks used by the Pentagon, the United Nations International Atomic Energy Agency and the International Criminal Court.
O’Shaughnessy said infection has not been confirmed there – only profiling of users. “But that alone is concerning, he said. “The ad system was built to send code from strangers to billions of screens with pinpoint targeting. Almost nobody was watching it from a security angle.”
The analyst said the risk remains low for most people as these attacks are expensive and aimed at specific targets. “For individuals at high risk, like journalists and officials, the best first defence is to install an ad blocker, switch off their advertising ID through their phone’s privacy settings, keep everything updated, and turn on Lockdown Mode or Android’s Advanced Protection,” he said.
Precautions also need to be taken within the industry and at government level. “To combat this, the ad industry needs to properly vet who’s buying ads,” O’Shaughnessy said, while “regulators need to stop personal data being sprayed out to thousands of unknown bidders in every auction.”
一种新型的“零点击”黑客技术利用广告来锁定目标受害者,而无需受害者采取任何行动。
半岛电视台周四发表声明,谴责针对其多名员工的间谍软件攻击。[Showkat Shafi/半岛电视台]
研究人员发现,仅仅访问网页或刷新应用程序就足以使你成为恶意软件攻击的受害者,导致你的个人数据从笔记本电脑或手机中被窃取。你甚至不需要点击任何内容。
以色列一家间谍软件公司被发现是首例已知的“零点击”定向广告的幕后黑手,在这种广告中,诈骗分子或间谍可以窃取私人数据并将其发送到外部服务器,半岛电视台的记者也是受害者之一。
列表 1/3 世界受审:记录以色列暴行的律师如何付出代价
报道称,欧盟三名议员中的第二名正在调查以色列间谍软件入侵的监控系统事件。
英国、美国和荷兰警告称,伊朗可能存在间谍软件(共3个名单中的第3个)。
2025 年 6 月,半岛电视台员工使用的 45 台设备(包括几位报道敏感话题的员工)成为间谍软件的目标,该软件无需打开或下载任何文件即可自行安装。
受半岛电视台对该事件的初步内部调查的启发,总部位于加拿大的学术研究机构 Citizen Lab 展开调查,发现以色列公司 Candiru 是这些攻击的幕后黑手。
分析人士表示,这些发现“令人极其担忧”,因为它们证实了一种新的全球安全威胁的存在。美国加州大学洛杉矶分校信息研究教授雷梅什·斯里尼瓦桑告诉半岛电视台:“我们知道我们正朝着这个方向发展,现在真相大白了。”
他说:“这已经是下一个阶段了,因为人们正被精准定位。这就是我们在监控方面所达到的程度。”
“零点击”恶意软件的工作原理
半岛电视台的内部技术团队于 2024 年首次发现一些记者使用的设备上存在异常模式。2025 年,半岛电视台向公民实验室提供的网络日志分析清晰地显示了攻击是如何执行的时间特征。
Discover-Tech 是一家以色列公司,该公司自称是一家合法的广告公司,但实际上却为雇佣间谍软件合作伙伴提供便利,该公司购买了恶意广告。
其广告网络识别出半岛电视台员工,然后悄悄地将他们重定向到Candiru公司一台受感染的服务器。这家间谍软件公司于2021年被美国政府列入黑名单,当时公民实验室发现该公司应对至少10个国家的100名活动人士、记者和政治活动人士的非法黑客攻击和监视负责。
半岛电视台谴责了针对其员工设备的攻击行为,并呼吁追究肇事者的责任。
网络安全分析师兼作家埃迪·威廉姆斯表示,这些广告一旦出现在屏幕上就会自动感染设备,但其中存在一个重要的技术细节。“在浏览器中执行代码并不意味着攻击者就能完全控制计算机,”威廉姆斯告诉半岛电视台。
Willems表示:“为了逃离浏览器的隔离环境——‘沙盒’——攻击者可能需要第二个漏洞。”他还补充说,高级间谍软件操作可以结合多个漏洞。
“攻击者试图利用漏洞绕过安全边界。这正是此类攻击如此危险的原因所在,”分析师表示。
一旦设备被感染,恶意软件就会收集各种敏感数据,包括文件、文档和浏览器数据,例如 cookie、书签和保存的凭据。
它还可以捕获键盘输入、截取屏幕截图、录制麦克风和摄像头输入,并从常用通讯平台提取电子邮件和消息。为了避免触发安全机制,该间谍软件通常使用加密通信通道,并将窃取的数据分成小块,分批发送。
广告:新的全球安全威胁?
分析人士表示,公民实验室的研究结果表明,现有威胁正在升级,这扩大了传统网络攻击的规模和范围,并使其更难被检测到。
虽然“零点击”攻击并非完全是新鲜事物,但研究结果揭示了一种利用在线广告作为感染途径的新技术。
爱尔兰都柏林理工大学布兰查斯敦校区网络安全讲师斯蒂芬·奥肖内西解释说,当用户打开网站或应用程序时,广告位会在瞬间通过自动拍卖售出。这种拍卖会共享有关受害者的数据,包括设备ID、IP地址、大致位置以及他们正在使用的应用程序或网站。
奥肖内西告诉半岛电视台:“Discover-Tech伪装成普通的广告商,利用这些数据找到目标用户,并赢得该用户屏幕的竞价。任何拥有手机或浏览器且会显示广告的人都可能成为目标,攻击者无需获取他们的电话号码或电子邮件地址。”
“因为没有涉及任何信息或链接,受害者几乎不会注意到任何事情,”他补充道。
Discover-Tech 出现在 Google 和广告行业协会 IAB Europe 维护的“认证”和“批准”供应商名单中,并通过 Google、Yandex 和 Beeswax 等主要网络投放广告。
公民实验室在其报告中指出,这表明在线广告系统存在结构性缺陷,该系统基本上未能检测或阻止滥用行为。
公民实验室发现,Discover-Tech 的广告出现在世界各地国家安全敏感网络人员使用的设备上,包括各个国防部、武装部队、国家网络机构、政府间组织和媒体机构。
该研究机构表示,这些广告也出现在联合国、北约、欧洲议会、欧盟委员会和欧盟理事会总秘书处使用的网络上。
“几乎没人看”
至少有24个国家的政府网络成为攻击目标,其中包括美国、意大利、丹麦、挪威、澳大利亚、俄罗斯、墨西哥以及以色列。据公民实验室(Citizen Lab)称,媒体机构的网络也成为攻击目标,主要集中在澳大利亚、丹麦和瑞典。
在另一份报告中,总部位于纽约的广告安全公司 Confiant 表示,其自身的调查发现,Discover-Tech 的一些广告也出现在五角大楼、联合国国际原子能机构和国际刑事法院使用的关键网络中。
奥肖内西表示,目前尚未证实该地区出现感染病例,仅有用户画像分析。“但仅此就令人担忧,”他说道。“这套广告系统旨在将陌生人的代码精准推送至数十亿个屏幕。几乎没有人从安全角度对其进行监控。”
分析师表示,对大多数人来说,风险仍然很低,因为这些攻击成本高昂且针对特定目标。“对于记者和官员等高风险人群,最佳的第一道防线是安装广告拦截器,通过手机隐私设置关闭广告ID,保持所有软件更新,并开启锁定模式或安卓高级保护功能。”他说道。
行业内部和政府层面也需要采取预防措施。奥肖内西表示:“为了应对这种情况,广告行业需要对广告购买者进行严格审查”,同时“监管机构需要阻止个人数据在每次竞价中被泄露给成千上万的未知竞标者”。