What we know about the ICE shooting in New York City

New York City has found itself mired in the Trump administration’s immigration crackdown after officials said federal agents shot a driver while his 5-year-old was in the back seat.

The Department of Homeland Security and city officials remain at odds over immigration agents’ tactics that led to them opening fire on 28-year-old Oscar Belgal . Federal officials accuse Belgal of trying to drive his Honda CRV into agents in the city’s Marble Hill neighborhood in the Bronx during a targeted enforcement operation.

DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin told CNN’s Jake Tapper that Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents acted appropriately, in part because New York refuses to honor the agency’s requests to detain undocumented people accused of crimes. New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani said there is no active warrant for Belgal’s arrest, and plainclothes ICE officers’ actions like those during Thursday’s daylight shooting on a busy street make New Yorkers less safe.

With this latest shooting, New York City finds itself in a familiar place as other American cities , such as Minneapolis, Houston and Chicago, that have seen ICE operations result in federal agents shooting people, often while in vehicles.

Some surveillance and police body camera footage has been released by the New York City Police Department, and Mullin says he expects video from ICE officers’ body cameras to be released.

As the shooting remains under investigation, here’s what to know.

Belgal, a Dominican national who officials say entered the US at an unknown date, has ties to the Trinitarios gang, according to DHS.

Mullin said he was part of an investigation into a shooting of a Customs and Border Protection officer last year and had previously fled from officers in September.

Belgal was arrested for robbery in 2023. He ultimately pleaded guilty to fourth-degree grand larceny and received five years of probation, according to New York court records.

He was also arrested last year on drug charges and has pleaded not guilty, court records show.

DHS has said Belgal had an immigration detainer, which allows ICE to take custody of immigrants in criminal custody, but Belgal was released after that earlier arrest.

Mamdani told MS NOW on Sunday there is no active warrant for Belgal’s arrest.

Now that Belgal’s in custody , ICE plans to quickly remove him from the country, according to Marcos Charles, executive associate director of the agency.

Belgal’s attorneys filed a petition for a writ of habeas corpus in federal court Friday, arguing he was arrested “without a valid warrant and without any consideration of his individual circumstances.”

US District Judge J. Paul Oetken then ordered Belgal to remain in the country for now.

In an update about his condition on Sunday, Belgal’s lawyers said he is in solitary confinement. With the bullet still lodged in his neck, the left side of his face is numb and he has difficulty hearing out of his left ear, according to a joint statement from the Legal Aid Society and Make the Road New York, two nonprofit advocacy organizations representing Belgal. He also has a shoulder wound from shattered glass during the shooting.

He urgently needs surgery but has yet to receive it, the statement said.

The shooting of Belgal highlights stark divides between deep-blue New York City and the Trump administration, even as Mamdani and President Donald Trump have formed an unlikely cordial relationship .

Mamdani has repeatedly called on ICE to be dismantled, calling the agency “rotten to its core.”

“Today’s shooting is only further devastating confirmation of what we have long known, which is that ICE operates with impunity, that they sow chaos and terror across our country, that they have killed far more of our neighbors than they could ever have claimed to save,” he said. “We will not normalize ICE’s viciousness. We will not accept its cruelty.”

Ryan Murphy/Getty Images

New York lawmakers also expressed outrage at ICE opening fire on a car with a child inside.

“No child should ever have to experience the terror of gunfire, let alone wonder if they’ll make it home alive,” Gov. Kathy Hochul said in a statement after the shooting . “As a mother and grandmother, I cannot imagine how frightening those moments must have been.”

Citing Belgal’s criminal history, Mullin has called him the “worst of the worst” and said he intentionally put his child at risk. Mullin blamed New York’s so-called sanctuary policies that limit local officials from cooperating with federal immigration enforcement.

“We asked the city to give them to us, and they released them back on the streets,” Mullin told CNN. “If anybody should be in outrage, it should be the public to the sanctuary states and the sanctuary politicians that continue to release these murderers and thugs back on the streets and put the American people in danger.”

The NYPD released body-camera footage showing officers responding to the scene after ICE officers shot and wounded a man in the Bronx on Thursday afternoon.

The footage begins with NYPD officers pulling up to a tense scene: A man in a construction vest is holding up a rifle, bystanders are yelling and a handcuffed man is sitting on the ground receiving treatment to his left neck.

Several officers lift up the injured man, place him into the back of the NYPD vehicle, and then drive away, the video shows. The officers later take the man out of the vehicle and carry him toward an ambulance.

The New York City Police Department has released surveillance footage of the incident, as well as video from police officers’ body-worn cameras when they responded to 911 calls after the shooting.

Surveillance footage released by the NYPD appears to show plainclothes ICE officers approach Belgal’s parked vehicle with their guns drawn. As he tries to move the car forward, an agent starts to punch the driver’s side window of the car, video shows.

The surveillance video then changes to another angle, which appears to show the aftermath of the shots being fired offscreen, as bystanders are seen ducking. Soon thereafter, an agent wearing plainclothes is seen holding a child, presumably Belgal’s 5-year-old, who was in the back seat of the vehicle at the time of the shooting.

Officers’ body cameras showed tense scenes of a man who appeared to be an ICE agent, wearing a construction vest holding up a rifle. Nearby, bystanders were yelling while a handcuffed man sat on the street receiving treatment to his neck.

While witnesses told NYPD that a 5-year-old had been in the car, a law enforcement source said the child wasn’t on scene when police arrived. Police went on a frantic hunt to find the child, resulting in detectives going door-to-door on the street, reviewing video footage and contacting Belgal’s family. It wasn’t until about 7 p.m. that police found the child, who wasn’t injured, with an aunt at a Yonkers beauty salon, the source said.

What isn’t directly shown on publicly released videos is the moment the shots were fired, prompting many to call on ICE to release footage from the agents’ body cameras. Mullin said Sunday he was sure footage would be released, though he didn’t provide a timeline. FBI and Homeland Security Investigations, which is part of ICE, are handling the investigation, Mullin said.

Bronx District Attorney Darcel Clark said her office would also investigate the shooting, which was supported by New York Attorney General Letitia James.

Eduardo Munoz/Reuters

Meanwhile, Mamdani said the city would be doing its own full investigation of the entire 24-hour period. He said this included the actual shooting, but also the NYPD response and ensuing protests outside a nearby hospital where Belgal was transported after being shot.

In the aftermath of Thursday’s shooting, NYPD clashed with demonstrators protesting ICE. During the scuffle, Mamdani ally Darializa Avila Chevalier, a democratic socialist and frontrunner to be the next congressperson representing the area where the incident took place, was knocked to the ground by NYPD. Mamdani said it was unacceptable to throw any New Yorker to the ground, regardless of whether she’s going to be in Congress.

CNN’s John Miller, Julianna Bragg, Alex Stambaugh and Eric Levenson contributed to this report.

纽约市发现自己陷入了特朗普政府的移民打击行动中，此前官员称，联邦特工开枪射杀了一名司机，当时他5岁的孩子就坐在后座上。

国土安全部和纽约市官员在移民执法人员向28岁的奥斯卡·贝尔加尔开枪的行动策略上仍然存在分歧。联邦官员指控贝尔加尔在布朗克斯区大理石山社区的一次有针对性的执法行动中，试图驾驶他的本田CRV冲撞执法人员。

美国国土安全部部长马克韦恩·穆林告诉CNN记者杰克·塔珀，移民和海关执法局（ICE）特工的行为是恰当的，部分原因是纽约州拒绝配合该机构拘留被控犯罪的无证移民的要求。纽约市市长佐兰·马姆达尼表示，目前没有针对贝尔加尔的有效逮捕令，而像周四在繁忙街道上光天化日之下枪击事件中那样的便衣ICE特工的行为，只会降低纽约市民的安全感。

纽约市最近发生的这起枪击事件，让纽约市再次陷入了似曾相识的境地，其他美国城市，如明尼阿波利斯、休斯顿和芝加哥，都曾发生过移民执法局（ICE）行动导致联邦特工向民众开枪的事件，而且往往是在车辆内。

纽约市警察局已经公布了一些监控录像和警用随身摄像头拍摄的视频，穆林表示，他预计美国移民及海关执法局（ICE）官员的随身摄像头拍摄的视频也将公布。

枪击事件仍在调查中，以下是您需要了解的情况。

据美国国土安全部称，贝尔加尔是多米尼加国民，官员称其入境美国的具体日期不明，他与特里尼塔里奥斯黑帮有联系。

穆林表示，他参与了对去年一起海关和边境保护官员枪击案的调查，并且此前曾在9月份逃离过执法人员。

贝尔加尔于 2023 年因抢劫罪被捕。根据纽约法院记录，他最终承认犯有四级重大盗窃罪，并被判处五年缓刑。

法庭记录显示，他去年也曾因毒品指控被捕，但他拒不不认罪。

国土安全部表示，贝尔加尔曾被移民局拘留，该拘留令允许移民局在刑事拘留期间拘留移民，但贝尔加尔在之前的逮捕后被释放。

Mamdani 周日告诉 MS NOW，目前没有针对 Belgal 的逮捕令。

据美国移民及海关执法局（ICE）执行副局长马科斯·查尔斯称，贝尔加尔已被拘留，ICE计划迅速将其驱逐出境。

贝尔加尔的律师周五向联邦法院提交了一份人身保护令申请，辩称他“在没有有效逮捕令且未考虑其个人情况的情况下”被捕。

美国地区法官 J. Paul Oetken 随后下令 Belgal 暂时留在美国。

周日，贝尔加尔的律师更新了他的病情，称他目前被单独监禁。代表贝尔加尔的两家非营利维权组织——法律援助协会和纽约援助之路——发表联合声明称，由于子弹仍留在他的颈部，他的左脸麻木，左耳听力受损。此外，他的肩膀也被枪击中时飞溅的碎玻璃划伤。

声明称，他急需手术，但尚未接受手术。

贝尔加尔被枪杀事件凸显了深蓝的纽约市与特朗普政府之间的巨大分歧，尽管马姆达尼和唐纳德·特朗普总统已经建立了一种不太可能的友好关系。

马姆达尼多次呼吁解散美国移民及海关执法局（ICE），称该机构“从骨子里就腐败不堪”。

“今天的枪击事件进一步令人痛心地证实了我们长期以来所知的事实，那就是美国移民及海关执法局（ICE）肆意妄为，在我们的国家散播混乱和恐怖，他们杀害的邻居远远多于他们声称拯救的人数，”他说。“我们绝不容忍ICE的残暴行径。我们绝不接受他们的残忍。”

Ryan Murphy/Getty Images

纽约州议员们也对美国移民及海关执法局向一辆载有儿童的汽车开枪表示愤慨。

“任何孩子都不应该经历枪声的恐惧，更不应该担心自己能否活着回家，”州长凯西·霍楚尔在枪击事件后发表声明说。“作为一名母亲和祖母，我无法想象那一刻该有多么可怕。”

穆林援引贝尔加尔的犯罪记录，称他是“罪大恶极之徒”，并表示他故意将自己的孩子置于危险之中。穆林将矛头指向纽约所谓的“庇护政策”，该政策限制地方官员与联邦移民执法部门合作。

穆林告诉CNN：“我们要求市政府把这些人交出来，但他们却把他们放回了街头。如果说谁应该感到愤怒，那应该是公众，应该谴责那些庇护州和庇护政客，他们不断释放这些杀人犯和暴徒，让他们重回街头，置美国人民于危险之中。”

纽约警察局公布了执法记录仪视频，显示周四下午在布朗克斯区，一名男子被移民及海关执法局（ICE）官员开枪击伤后，警员们赶到现场的情况。

视频开始时，纽约警察局的警员们来到一个紧张的现场：一名身穿建筑背心的男子举着一支步枪，旁观者们大声叫喊，一名戴着手铐的男子坐在地上，正在接受左颈的治疗。

视频显示，几名警员抬起受伤男子，将其放入纽约警局警车后座，然后驾车离开。随后，警员们将该男子从车内抬出，送往救护车。

纽约市警察局公布了该事件的监控录像，以及警员在枪击事件发生后接听 911 报警电话时佩戴的执法记录仪拍摄的视频。

纽约警察局公布的监控录像显示，便衣移民执法局（ICE）官员持枪靠近贝尔加尔停放的车辆。录像显示，当贝尔加尔试图将车向前移动时，一名官员开始猛击驾驶座一侧的车窗。

监控录像随后切换到另一个角度，画面似乎显示了枪击事件发生后的场景，旁观者纷纷躲避。不久之后，一名便衣特工抱着一个孩子，据推测是贝尔加尔5岁的孩子，枪击发生时他正坐在车后座。

警员的执法记录仪拍下了紧张的画面：一名身穿建筑背心、疑似美国移民及海关执法局（ICE）特工的男子手持步枪。附近，一名戴着手铐的男子坐在街上接受颈部治疗，旁观者大声叫喊。

目击者告诉纽约警察局，车里有一名5岁儿童，但一位执法部门消息人士称，警方到达现场时，孩子并不在场。警方随即展开紧急搜寻，侦探挨家挨户走访，查看监控录像，并联系了贝尔加尔的家人。消息人士称，直到晚上7点左右，警方才在扬克斯一家美容院找到了这名未受伤的儿童，当时孩子正和她的姑姑在一起。

公开视频中并未直接显示枪击发生的瞬间，这促使许多人呼吁美国移民及海关执法局（ICE）公布执法人员随身摄像头拍摄的视频。穆林周日表示，他确信视频将会公布，但他没有给出具体时间表。穆林还表示，联邦调查局（FBI）和国土安全调查局（隶属于ICE）正在负责此案的调查。

布朗克斯区检察官达塞尔·克拉克表示，她的办公室也将对这起枪击事件展开调查，纽约州总检察长莱蒂西亚·詹姆斯对此表示支持。

爱德华多·穆尼奥斯/路透社

与此同时，马姆达尼表示，市政府将对整个24小时期间的情况进行全面调查。他说，调查内容不仅包括枪击事件本身，还包括纽约市警察局的应对措施，以及随后在贝尔加尔中枪后被送往的附近医院外发生的抗议活动。

周四枪击事件发生后，纽约警察局与抗议美国移民及海关执法局（ICE）的示威者发生冲突。冲突中，马姆达尼的盟友、民主社会主义者、也是事发地区下一任国会议员的热门人选达里亚利扎·阿维拉·谢瓦利埃被纽约警察局的警察推倒在地。马姆达尼表示，无论她是否会进入国会，将任何纽约市民推倒在地都是不可接受的。

CNN的约翰·米勒、朱莉安娜·布拉格、亚历克斯·斯坦博和埃里克·莱文森对本报道亦有贡献。